Members only

The Back Room

The conversation that happens after the shop closes: what we'd actually buy, what we'd avoid, and where the value hides.

Buy the amp, not the pedal

If you're choosing between a boutique overdrive and a used tube combo at the same price, buy the combo every time. A good power section makes cheap pedals sound expensive; no pedal makes a bad amp sound good.

The 90s Japanese sleeper market

Late-80s and 90s MIJ instruments were built to a standard nobody advertises now. The finishes are thinner, the fretwork is often better than modern equivalents twice the price, and the market still prices them as 'not American'.

Speakers are the cheapest tone change you're not making

A speaker swap alters more of your sound than most pedal purchases. Before you replace an amp you basically like, spend a fraction of that on a different driver and re-judge it.

Player-grade beats collector-grade

Refinished, repaired and route-modified vintage instruments sound identical to untouched ones and cost a fraction. Buy the guitar with a story unless you're buying an asset instead of an instrument.

Members' shortlist

If you only buy one thing this year

TGP may earn a commission when you purchase through select gear links. It never changes what you pay or what we recommend. Full disclosure.